This is a double-points review! I read this book for the Children’s Lit discussion group and also for the Back to the Classics Challenge. It is true: I am unlikely to ever visit Middle Earth.
I’ve always loved this book. My first memory of it is my family sitting around the living room, listening to my mother read it aloud, begging for just one more chapter. So that probably biases me toward putting it in the “books that have my undying devotion” category.
It is a classic quest story: an unlikely hero is swept into a grand adventure involving dragons, treasure, mythical creatures, a hint of magic, and camping in the rain*.
In between the last time I read this (years ago) and this reading, I read Tolkien’s epic Lord of the Rings trilogy. Reading The Hobbit again, it surprised me to realize it is less, well, epic. But it hangs together more as a story and less of a history, which I appreciate too.
Part of what is great about this story is that Bilbo Baggins starts out as a loveable and unlikely hero. Yes, we read that there is a hidden strain of adventuring in his blood, but to all outward appearances at the beginning of the story, he has settled down to an ordinary, respectable existence. He just wants teatime to remain undisturbed.
But Gandalf, the wise mentor and wizard, knows better, and sends him off on crazy adventures that lead him to dangerous places and make everyone realize there is more to him than even he had any idea of.
One thing that stood out to me in this book was how action-packed it can be: each chapter is a new adventure. But the pacing doesn’t feel rushed (mostly), which I appreciated.
The other thing that stood out was Tolkien’s asides to the reader and some of his descriptions. It is clear that he enjoyed writing this book, and while he dips occasionally into brief motivations and moral dilemmas, this book does not deal with long histories or dwell on inward reflection. We see the lighter side of the elves, as they sing silly songs to travelers arriving in their valley, and can almost forget their sad history told in The Silmarillion and mentioned in The Lord of the Rings.
While I did not come away with any great revelations about human nature, Tolkien presented an enjoyable story in which characters do grow and which stirs the imagination without becoming ridiculous. It’s a fast read, and worth a few hours of anyone’s time.
*Every quest story involves camping in the rain. I’ve come to believe it’s just part of the formula.

Posted by austin 



